For years, we fought for women to be better informed about their health. To understand their bodies. To ask questions. To advocate for themselves. To stop accepting that feeling exhausted, gaining weight, losing muscle, sleeping poorly or struggling through menopause was simply something they had to put up with.
It was supposed to be about empowerment.
But somewhere along the way, I think we have started moving in the opposite direction.
Spend five minutes scrolling through social media or watching the latest health advertising and you will notice a recurring message aimed particularly at women:
It's your hormones.
It's your genetics.
It's your metabolism.
It's menopause.
It's your biology.
And increasingly: there's a medication for that.
The language often sounds compassionate. And some of it is well intentioned. Women absolutely have been dismissed medically, particularly around menopause, reproductive health and metabolic health. Genetics absolutely influence our health. Hormones matter. Biology matters. And medications, including GLP-1 therapies and menopausal hormone therapy, can be enormously valuable when clinically appropriate.
But there is an important difference between removing shame and removing agency.
And I worry we are increasingly confusing the two.
"It's not your fault" can become "there's nothing you can do"
Telling a woman that her biology contributes to her weight, cholesterol, blood glucose, symptoms or disease risk can be incredibly validating.
But if the conversation stops there, we haven't empowered her.
We may have done the opposite.
Because the message she can easily hear is: "This is happening to you because of something outside your control."
And the next message is conveniently: "Here is the product that can fix it."
That is an extraordinarily powerful marketing proposition.
We are now surrounded by advertising that rarely needs to name the condition or product directly. We are encouraged to "talk to your doctor". We are told there may be an underlying biological explanation for why our previous efforts haven't worked.
Again, sometimes there is.
But human health is rarely that simple.
Your genes are not an instruction manual dictating your inevitable future. Menopause is not a disease that suddenly renders nutrition, exercise, sleep and metabolic health irrelevant. A family history of high cholesterol does not mean lifestyle has no role in cardiovascular risk. And having a predisposition to insulin resistance or weight gain does not mean you are powerless to influence your metabolic health.
Predisposition is not destiny.
Women deserve more than reassurance
For more than 30 years working in nutrition and metabolic health, one of the most powerful things I have watched happen is the moment someone finally understands what is going on inside their own body.
Why their blood glucose changes.
Why muscle matters.
Why protein becomes increasingly important as we age.
Why sleep affects appetite and insulin sensitivity.
Why eating patterns matter.
Why visceral fat matters.
Why strength training can change far more than the number on the scales.
Why their pathology results are not simply numbers to be filed away until next year's blood test.
Knowledge changes behaviour because suddenly there is a reason for the behaviour.
That is empowerment.
Empowerment isn't telling a woman that none of this is her responsibility.
It is giving her enough knowledge to understand what she can influence, while acknowledging what she cannot.
There is an enormous difference.
Medication and personal agency can coexist
This shouldn't become another polarised argument about medication versus lifestyle.
That serves nobody.
If a woman needs menopausal hormone therapy, she should have access to it and receive appropriate medical advice.
If someone meets the clinical criteria for a GLP-1 medication and it helps improve their health, that treatment may be valuable.
If someone has a strong genetic predisposition to high cholesterol and requires medication to reduce cardiovascular risk, lifestyle should not be presented as a substitute for necessary treatment.
But neither should medication become a substitute for understanding your health.
A prescription cannot teach you how to preserve muscle as you age.
It cannot strength train for you.
It cannot create a healthy sleep routine.
It cannot choose your food.
It cannot build your cardiovascular fitness.
And it cannot give you the health literacy required to make informed decisions for the next 30 years.
These things are not insignificant "lifestyle tips". They are fundamental components of long-term health.
We need to stop underestimating women
There is something strangely patronising about the idea that empowerment means constantly reassuring women that their health is happening to them.
Women are capable of hearing a far more nuanced message:
Some things are outside your control.
Some things are harder because of your biology.
Sometimes you will need medical treatment.
And there is still an enormous amount you can do.
This has always been the philosophy behind what I do. The goal isn't to make someone dependent upon me indefinitely. It is to help people understand their metabolism, pathology, nutrition, movement and lifestyle well enough that eventually they don't need someone constantly telling them what to do.
I want a woman to understand why she is eating a particular way, not simply follow a meal plan.
I want her to understand her blood results, not simply be told they are "normal".
I want her to understand why maintaining muscle at 50, 60 and 70 matters.
I want her to understand what is changing during menopause and, importantly, what she can do about it.
Because the most valuable health intervention isn't necessarily the one that makes you dependent on it.
Sometimes it is the knowledge that makes you less dependent.
Your body isn't something happening to you
We should absolutely continue talking about the biological realities of women's health.
We should continue correcting decades of dismissal and inadequate research.
We should remove shame from obesity, menopause, metabolic disease and chronic illness.
But removing shame does not require removing responsibility.
Responsibility doesn't mean blame.
It means recognising that your daily decisions have power.
That is a fundamentally different message from "it's not your fault, therefore there's nothing you can do".
Women deserve better than that.
The most empowering health message we can give someone isn't that their biology doesn't matter.
It's this:
Your biology matters. Your genetics matter. Your hormones matter.
But so do you.
And there is far more within your influence than modern health marketing would sometimes have you believe.
Ā






